When Taika began teaching
RyuTe® (as opposed to Ryukyu Kempo), He was teaching (even more so) his own system of life
protection. Keep in mind that Taika taught only Yudansha level
students. All Mudansha training was left to the (his) Yudansha
students to oversee (each in their own manner).
Mudansha were considered
to be the concern of each of the Yudansha students that trained with
Taika. When they (the Mudansha student) came to him to test for their
Yudansha grading, they were expected to be familiar with all
of the Mudansha requirements. This was not always the case.
It was a well understood
fact, that the testing student's would be expected to perform
Naihanchi Shodan for Taika (Taika felt he could tell more of a
students ability's by watching them do this kata, than by any
other means). A few of the more questionable
schools/instructors would have their student's (who were often conversion Yudansha ranked students, from other systems) study the (3)
Naihanchi kata, then send them to test (in front of Taika) for a
Yudansha ranking.
In addition to performing
kata, testing students would be given an assignment (of sorts, LOL).
Usually this would be some form of exercise/motions, that the testing
students would work on for the few days of the summer conference, and
would (then) receive their Yudansha certificate at the dinner on
Saturday evening.
I've heard of numerous
testing protocol's that are utilized in various schools/systems. The
majority amount to being Hazing ceremonies (more than being
any manner of “test”). Just how (exactly) does standing in
regiment for 2 hours (in a Horse stance), performing punches,
equate to meeting the qualifications for a Yudansha ranking?
The really sad
part being, the majority of the people overseeing these types of
“tests”, couldn't perform those same (physical)
requirements if their life depended on it (all the while,
Ignoring the fact, that the ability to do so, has
nothing to do with one's ability to protect themselves,
and/or demonstrate the knowledge/ability to instruct others in
the basic requirements of the system).
Many of these tests are
more endurance competitions than any manner of testing
procedure. The standard test, is really no more than a review
of what the student can remember (spur of the moment). An
actual Test, would be a categorized review of the systems
entire syllabus (very time consuming, not cost
effective, and actually kind of pointless, LOL).
Any instructor worth
their salt, can tell you exactly how well any of their student's are
doing (overall). They may be unaware of individual (student) difficulties
and/or knowledge levels, but I've yet to see an instructor
that was oblivious to their student's ability level.
The dominant
questions regarding your system's Yudansha testing requirements are,
what does your system require to be a (Shodan) Yudansha rank student?
Will you be considered qualified to teach the (basic) system's requirements? Are you
only required to be able to perform certain motions? Do you
have to explain any of your system's theory's, or methodology's
?
Regardless which (if
any) of these would be similar to what your system may
require, what are those minimal requirements? You may be
surprised at what and how minimal those “minimal” requirements (often)
turn out to be.
I have heard that
the RyuTe®
association's testing committee is going to (begin) requiring any/all
of the testing student's instructors to also be present at
their student's testing (albeit outside of the actual testing
room), “on-call” if you will (to answer to/for any major
deficiency's). It was determined that the student should not
be held accountable for the instructor's mistakes (whether it
was in improper instruction, or in poor judgment for
submitting the student to test).
I believe this to be a
supreme idea. Having witnessed students being chastised
for things that were beyond their control or knowledge (in the
past), I believe the instructor should be held accountable for
their student's performance. I also believe there should also be
consequences for having (obviously) unjustly submitted
applicants for testing.
I've been frustrated with
the whole dismissal of any personal responsibility
regarding one's students for some time now. At least in theory,
student's attend a class in order to (actually) learn
something. How about instructor's doing their job (teaching),
that their being payed by those students to do.
Student's attend a class
(at least usually, LOL) to learn the subject that the class
teaches (or at least what it advertises to teach). One would
hope that this was discussed between the student and the
instructor before having began the class.
If/when those
expectations aren't being met, there should be some
form/manner of inquiry in place so that (both) the student and
the school/instructor are able to establish an explanation (if not the ability to negotiate a solution).
As instructor's, we are
(only) a service provider (much like an Ice Cream Shop,
there's plenty of other Ice Cream Shop's in town, they may not
sell the exact same Ice Cream, but most people neither
know the difference, or care).
RyuTe®
provides instruction
in Taika Oyata's system of Life Protection. The majority of student's
are happy with their “kicky-punchy” krotty.
RyuTe® will only (ever) appeal to the technical geeks of the martial arts world. The vast majority of student's are not those (types of) student's.
RyuTe® will only (ever) appeal to the technical geeks of the martial arts world. The vast majority of student's are not those (types of) student's.
Those
that choose to consider/call us elitist's
are not orientated
towards achieving that
same level of technical ability.
We may not reach it either,
but We
won't just settle
for achieving the lower
levels of our abilities, or spend our time chasing after stupid mythological pursuits (to explain why whatever their doing doesn't work). Our
goal, is to evolve
our ability's to the highest level that we are able to. Not to drop those standards in order to meet the lower expectations of those not committed to learning, and understanding the teachings of Taika.
No comments:
Post a Comment