Oyata Te

Oyata Te
(Link to Oyata Te info.)

Okishikan/Kenshukai Dojo

Okishikan/Kenshukai Dojo
(Link to Our Dojo)

Saturday, June 18, 2016

Kata, Calligraphy and Bunkai




  I am often asked why I practice Oriental brush calligraphy. It (seemingly) has little to do with the Life Protection methods that I study and teach. First, I just happen to enjoy it, second, it is composed of a number of intricacies that are very similar to the defensive methodology that I practice (that of Seiyu Oyata). I additionally liken it to the practice of kata (of which there are numerous similarities).

  When our students are shown the beginning kata motions, they are provided with the general motions. As the student defines those motions they are guided in their own individual refinements for performing those motions (as was taught to us by Taika Oyata).
  The same is true for my brush calligraphy student's study and practice. They are initially shown the general motions (strokes) and those strokes are refined until they are performed in the manor recognized as being “correct". As with the kata, those individual motions will be performed by the student (through numerous individual aspects) in their own manner, yet will adhere to the instructed methodology (in our students case, those methodology's will consist of Oyata's (Life Protection Methods), and the Japanese Calligraphy Assoc. {Nihon Shuji) for the brush calligraphy being shown.

  In either subject, the motions could be performed by “other” students (of different methodology's) in various (different) manners. That's not to say one is (necessarily) better than another, only that there will be differences. Those differences really amount to differences of purpose. The purpose of Oyata's methodology is efficiency in the practice of Life Protection applications, the purpose of the Nihon Shuji methodology is beauty (granted, a relative term) in the creation of Oriental Brush Calligraphy. These are two seemingly different pursuits, but they share numerous commonality's in their study and practice.

  When practicing the instructed kata motions, the student is attempting to reproduce the motions in the manner taught, while maintaining correct stature and breathing (during those motions). The same is true for brush calligraphy. When any of those subjects are neglected, the entire process suffers (or is performed incorrectly).

  This is how (or why) observing a (possible) “opponent” performing kata could deter one from engaging in a confrontation with that person. When an experienced shodoka views a piece of calligraphy, they (likewise) can “see” the skill level of that person's calligraphy.

  In either subject (kata performance or brush calligraphy), the experienced practitioner should be able to see the level of the performer's abilities (in that subject). Students (of either subject) who only strive to “reproduce” those motions, are readily seen to be “beginners”. Those that can “perform” the actions (fluidly), and without conscious effort, are seen as knowledgeable (if not skilled) in/of the subject.

  Kata motion represents more than just the “obvious” motion(s) being performed. Interpreting those motions is known as “bunkai”. Deciphering the (numerous) interpretations for those motions, involves serious study for the applicable interpretation of them.  
 The majority of whats commonly being presented (as being bunkai) is IMO, more often simplistic “battering” applications. Though (possibly) valid, they are more often only applicable via (physical) size, force and strength. None of which are elements of/for advanced study or application. Motion and positioning are the more relevant factors to the applicable bunkai.

  One may ask what the connection to brush calligraphy is? It must first be understood that the Tensho (style) is the oldest style of Oriental (brush) writing. These were based upon pictographs. They were then modified via various changes to create the other (common) styles of brush calligraphy (Sosho, Gyosho, Reisho, Kaisho, etc.). Tensho is (kind of) the “bunkai” of the present day Kaisho (style). Without understanding how calligraphy transitioned through the various “style” changes, it would be difficult to understand what the original “Tensho” (style) consisted of (for the character).

  When attempting to interpret kata motion, the most difficult part (IMO), is determining where to begin, and where to end? (for the relevant motions). Even when those motions are decided upon, a “full/complete” technique/application may require additional motions (and often from multiple kata).

  Many people (when trying to decipher kata motions) attempt to make the motions fit (often) bizarre situations (IMO), or represent motions that they already know (believing that bunkai is only simplistic representations of equally simplistic defensive motions). This doesn't make sense? (for a technique/system mnemonic). Much less for what are generally considered to be “secret” techniques of/for a defensive system that someone wants to remain secret.

I believe the motions are (more so) representative of commonly utilized (if not general) defensive motions that can be utilized in various ways, and in commonly encountered defensive situations. This implies the motions are more akin to application “principles” (as opposed to specific techniques). That doesn't make the interpretations simplistic, just not readily recognized (hence the need for “research”).

  This is why we spend (a lot of) time with researching individual kata motions. Using the examples provided to us by Oyata, has given us numerous directions, methods and means to apply those concepts to kata motion (for both defensive actions and the application of Tuite). For myself, Shuji is a constant reminder of those concepts and origins.






Wednesday, May 4, 2016

Thieves


Updated May 22(see below article)



  Wow, I was fully aware that the many of the Krotty schools out there were run by “less than respectable” individuals, but I “presumed” that they were more subtle than what I encountered last evening (while cruising the Internet).

  A page was brought to my attention, so I checked it out. Low and behold, there's a copy of the Dojo Principles that my associate and myself brushed, and put together. But ODDLY ENOUGH, it had been altered. Though retaining my brushed kanji (within the subject matter, I.E. The Dojo Principles), they “cut and pasted” their own style, names onto it. They also (obviously) redid the title (and “that” was supposed to fool someone???).

  No doubt as soon as this post is up, they will be removing it. Why? Because I am going to post the schools name, website and group affiliation. These people are thieves (the brushwork is mine, not theirs), they then have the audacity to place a “copyright” post on it! (WTF!!!). I have no-doubt that the “©” mark is invalid (they just put it on there to impress someone, AND they don't know how “copyright laws” work, LOL). IF, they were stupid enough to attempt to copyright the piece (and received one) I may become a VERY well to do (financially) individual! falsifying a copyright validation is considered a felony and/or can be very COSTLY to fight (or in this case settle) and I can EASILY provide the proof of their having done so (We have all the originals from the project).

  These dirt-bags even dated it 2015 (the “copywrite”) yet, the date on their plagiarized copy is “2010 (?) the variances in the piece are obvious (where they added their own kanji).

  In the past (for the most part) I have (usually) refrained from directly “bad-mouthing” most individuals and/or organizations, these thieves (within this group) in particular were avoided because of a prior (20+years ago was the last contact) association to/with their groups leader to Oyata (despite any claims made otherwise by them or any of their minions).

  This THIEVING SCHOOL is the “” dojo. They are a member of the RYUKYU KEMPO RENMEI (aka the "Ryukyu alliance), "Google it", they're also on "Facebook".  They (RKA) like to “quote” their leader's sayings (which were commonly and originally heard from Oyata), but are presented on their website(s) as if their (present) leader had originated them (very much like MY brush calligraphy being presented as if “they” had brushed it).

  This website “(no longer listed, see below)” doesn't list a location/address (?), on any of the sites linked to upon it (that I found), so I have to assume that they are aware of their thieving of the aforementioned artwork (and can thus avoid legal servings). 
*UPDATE I (finally) found that they are in NEW YORK, USA. (thus, making them more easy to prosecute).  

  It was asked of me if I should “discreetly” inquire into this matter, I promptly stated that “NO” I should NOT. IMO anyone so STUPID and/or so arrogant to think that they can blatantly steal someone else's artwork/calligraphy (and imply that they did it) can kiss my (and my lawyer's) ass.

  I have in the past (and even the present) provided calligraphy for individuals (often at no charge). What pisses me off, is that they simply stole it, then presented it as being theirs! (though never directly stating as such). 
 If this is "typical" for the behavior of these guys, then I would advise anyone to avoid any affiliation with them and/or their organization. 
 Though (by no means) an "expert" (at brush calligraphy), I have been practicing/studying brush calligraphy for over 20 years. I am a certified instructor of/for the Japanese Calligraphy Association. I hold an instructor's license (Menkyojo) for teaching that art and I provide both weekly and seminar instruction for the practice of it.
 Being that I do so (for a price), means that this organization is stealing my work (thus my ability to profit from my trained skill) and provides grounds for me to move forward with litigation against them.
 Though having presented (smaller) examples of our piece (NEVER for "public" use), someone (?) had (obviously) "copied" it from the RyuTe® Website (which is copyright protected, yet They seem to have ignored) and began "photoshopping" it to "create"{sic} their own version (which could have been legally/properly created via a simple request). This was simply an attempt to make (steal) something for "personal" gain/profit.



BTW, Here is their "altered" copy:


 And here, is our Original:

 

it doesn't take an art expert to see it was "copied" (and altered).

(added 5/22/16)
It's been over 3 weeks, so these "%#*-hat's" are completely incompetent or just don't give a F@*K that they are THIEVES. 


a false statement of a material fact,
  • Martial Arts Fraud:
  • Registered trademarks provide constructive notice to the public of the registrant’s claim of ownership of the mark, so ignorance is not a defense and any statements contrary to said ownership are false
  • Registered trademarks provide a legal presumption of the registrant’s ownership of the mark and the registrant’s exclusive right to use the mark nationwide on or in connection with the goods and/or services listed in the registration and any statements contrary to said exclusivity are false
    • False statements of fact are present when trademark infringement or trademark counterfeiting occur because the underlying martial art instruction, credentials, products, etc. which are being provided to the student are not regulated by, originated by or authorized by the trademark owner. 
    • False statements of fact occur when a studio or instructor engages in unauthorized use of registered trademarks 
    • False statements of fact occur when a studio’s ads, web sites, etc. when they feature unauthorized registered trademarks
    • False statements of fact occur when a studio’s promotional literature bears unauthorized registered trademarks
    • False statements of fact occur when a studio’s application forms bear unauthorized registered trademarks
    • False statements of fact occur when prospective students are told by a studio owner, instructor or a staff member during enrollment presentations that the student will be learning a trademarked martial art system (that the studio is not licensed to teach).
    • False statements of fact occur when counterfeit certificates and credentials bearing unauthorized registered trademark are used to induce new student enrollments


Update:   

    The owner of the web site previously listed above (finally) contacted me. There was much apologies, and statements made that "his web guy (girl?)" was provided with the material to "make" a dojo principles "sheet"(?). At any rate that person (evidently) got lazy and just took ours and changed the logo and a few kanji (as anyone can see by the examples above). 
 Regardless of who was at fault, it has been removed. It only required (me) finally bringing it to his attention (after being posted here for 3 weeks), and it was attended to (ie."removed"). If asked, I would advise that the individual check the material being posted on his "web-site" more closely in the future. 
 Though having corrected the situation, and having apologized (profusely) and "I" having accepted that apology, this particular "blog" post will remain (for the next 2 weeks), after that time I will be removing the name of the offending dojo and the individuals names only, this blog will remain (that's the price you pay, for not monitoring your website, IMO, pretty "cheap" penalty). Plagiarism is a serious offense (both monetarily, and ethically), Hence, you should monitor your website more seriously). As long as the work (ie. "My" calligraphy) isn't utilized, I will not be pursuing any further legal action in this matter. 







 

Thursday, April 21, 2016

Seminar Instruction







 I recently decided to see what has been being promoted among similarly provided seminars in regards to “Tuite” (and/or similar methods) over the past few months (if not years). I usually do so just to prepare myself for the most commonly asked (types of) questions and comments that we are likely to receive (in comparison/regards to those alternate methods).
  Aside from the commonly (and mistakenly) made correlation to “Kyusho”, the only other “methodology” currently being offered is the manner being promoted by the DKS/ Ryukyu Kenpo school(s).
  IMO, what they are presenting is their own version of “Tori Te”, and not Oyata's Tuite. They (regularly) imply that it is derived from Oyata's methodology (via GD), but it is implemented very differently. This is evidenced through their (subsequent) instructional seminars, and the publicly provided information in regards to that implementation.
  Many of those other methods can/will work (to varying degrees), but they are different from how and what Oyata taught (for his method of application).
  Understanding Oyata's form of Tuite, requires more than attendance at a weekend/day/”?”-hour seminar. Unfortunately, many of the seminars that we have been teaching recently have had been limited in the time being allowed for us to teach those methods.  
 Our (minimum) allotted time is (usually) 4 hours (for instruction of the 6 Basic Principles of Tuite). This time it will be 2 hours (though provided at multiple times). This will still allow us to teach/explain each of those 6 (basic) Principles more fully, and will provide sufficient time for the students to apply those principles in the application of individual techniques (and will allow the time necessary to provide individual instruction/correction of the principles within those applications). Each of the 6 Principles contain elements that can facilitate a techniques application (when done correctly) or can/will prevent it's occurrence when done incorrectly. This time period also allows for attendees/students to ask any individual questions.
  What is commonly being taught (by others) are vague suggestions, that don't provide students with solid “Right/Wrong” guidelines to refer to while practicing a techniques application. The 6 Basic Tuite Principles were designed to provide those guidelines for students to refer to while learning/refining their application of an instructed technique.
  Oyata emphasized that Tuite (techniques) are not dependent upon the size or strength of (either) the student (tori) nor their opponent (uke). Many of the commonly taught methods emphasize the use of speed for (their) techniques to even work. Oyata's (Tuite) techniques had no such “requirement”. ALL of Oyata's Tuite techniques can be performed slowly (and be easily controlled) when done correctly. Though speed would be a consideration if/when using those techniques in an actual defensive situation, it is far from necessary in a training (I.E. learning) situation.
  I am regularly confronted with (supposed) students from the years following Oyata's initial arrival (mid-late “70's”/early 80's”, and yes, I was there as well). Their arguments against this (slow-speed) manner of practice is based upon (their own) misunderstanding of Oyata's instructional methods. Oyata (at seminars) would commonly demonstrate a technique (doing so at ½ to ¾ speed), and would then have everyone (attempt to) reproduce what he had just demonstrated. He would also state that students should practice slowly, until they understood what was involved with making the technique work (correctly). That portion of his instruction was (usually) dismissed by those attendee's during their practice (supposedly in the attempt to appear competent in the techniques use).
  Because most would fail at their own implementation of the technique (when doing so slowly), they would be inclined to speed up that attempt (to achieve some sort of result). That increase of speed would additionally include a (generous) use of muscular strength (if not physical weight) as well. The vast majority of Oyata's form of Tuite techniques can be performed (incredibly) sloppily, and still achieve a “reaction” (by the uke). That reaction is rarely the optimal/preferred reaction, but any reaction is often sufficient (“good-enough”) for those who don't really understand what “optimal” amounts to.
  Oyata's methodology was so (radically) different from what most of these early (often Yudansha) attendee's were accustom to, that their (own) “corrections” (although wrong) were accepted as being a correct application of the instructed techniques (at least by themselves). At “seminars”, Oyata would rarely (if ever) “correct” those attendee's, as they were often content with their own results, and they were not (really) “his” students. Oyata just presumed that they would continue their study with him, and they could/would be corrected later (little did he realize, LOL).
  The 6 Principles of Tuite, are a modest portion of the (numerous) principles and application guidelines that Oyata had provided to us over the past 30+ years in the use of his methodology. We've taken a (directly) relevant portion of those guidelines, and are demonstrating their use/application in a defined portion of Oyata's Life Protection methodology (“Tuite Jutsu”). There are additional principles that are utilized as well, but for introductory purposes, these 6 Principles will provide (more than enough) direct application use, to keep the average student/instructor in research/practice application for some time.
  Though our upcoming seminar (July 2016, Kansas City Missouri) will include instruction in numerous Okinawan and Oyata taught/related subjects, my own emphasis and instruction will be with The 6 Principles of Tuite and the instruction of/for the Introduction to Brush Calligraphy (Chinese/Japanese) classes. There will be a number of Association instructors present to convey instruction in/for the numerous included subjects as well (it's not a “singular” subject seminar). This seminar will be “open” to anyone who wishes to attend. There are a couple of “Association” (member) only classes, but there will be (up to three 3) classes available (and being taught) at most any time throughout the 3 day event (a limited number of subject classes will be provided multiple times due to requested interest levels). 






 

Saturday, March 19, 2016

Kumite








  I read an article recently that expounded upon the various “fallacies” taught within the martial arts community. Many of those observations I agreed with, but the author directed his “rant” to include the need/necessity for the inclusion of “sparring”. I've lamented upon this practice (repeatedly) in prior blogs. It's now “popular” to use the term “reality based”, though the practice itself has nothing to do with the subject. None of the “examples” presented look (anywhere) near to my own, or any of the confrontations that I've witnessed.




  The referenced authors arguments mirrored (many) of my own disagreements (though I believe his intent was to present them as “positive” reasons to do so). Some of those “reasons” were the following.



“Sparring teaches you how the techniques will work in a confrontation (“fight”)”



  This is only (moderately) true if you have clearly missed the “pre-fight” situation. The “physical” part of a confrontation rarely begins with an aggressor walking up to you and throwing a random “punch”. There is always some form of additional interaction (usually verbal) between the two individuals (this isn't necessarily the case when the confrontation is criminal, of which the majority of confrontations are not).

  “Fights” do not begin with both individuals being in “Krotty” stances, they are (usually) at arm's length distance with their hands at their sides or positioned to their front or side. The “confrontation is usually verbal, and done at a distance. When they do (finally) approach one another, One or both, may have something in their hands (glass, bottle, etc,). They may (or may not) have their “dominant-side” foot to their rear. “This” positioning is far more common (depending on the situation) and is “visually” declaring an intent to engage. If/when you vary from your initial positioning (defensively), it is often considered to be an “acceptance” to engage in any (possible) confrontation. Whether remaining in a natural stance should be considered as being a “weaker” positioning (IE. Remaining in a “natural” stance, and standing “square”, IE.”facing” the aggressor), is debatable.

  Regardless of how the aggressor is standing (when they approach), numerous “signs” are provided if/when any physical aggression is began (prior to the actual impact of a strike). The #1 manner that a confrontation begins, is the delivery of a “face/head” punch. It can be argued about “why” this is so, but regardless of the exact reason, It remains the most commonly attempted “first strike” (by an aggressor), when a confrontation becomes “physical”. This is usually preceded by varying amounts of “verbal sex” (“F-you, no, F-you” etc.).

  The practice of “sparring”, develops the tendency to only feel “comfortable” when one begins (the confrontation) while in a “fighting” stance. This (often) results in a “trained” individual stepping “back” into their preferred (“fighting”) stance. Aside from this being non-productive (serving no real purpose), it telegraph's the person's intent (to begin the confrontation). If/when the person isn't in one of those practiced stances, they don't “feel” comfortable/ready (to begin).

  Oyata taught that the “natural” stance, is where one should practice “all” of their defensive motions/techniques from (as one is “in” that stance 90% of the time). The instructed stances are to provide stability during or immediately following a techniques delivery. Beginning in one of those stances (prior to a confrontation) serves no purpose, other than alerting the aggressor to your having received some degree of training.



“Sparring teaches the student to “take”(sic) a punch”



  This statement is just stupid (as well as being inaccurate). No one “learns” to take a punch, they may learn to not complain about being hit, but the strike will still produce some level of injury. In an actual confrontation, the body will release endorphin's (which will tend to nullify many of the minor “pains”) but any (actual) injury will remain. One's ability to continue a confrontation will be motivated by one's (basic) “survival instinct”.

  The statement is a misogynistic fallacy (“it makes you tough”). The purpose of training is not to make you into a “fighting machine”, it's intended to train you to prevent being injured (ie. “survive”) when being involved in a physical confrontation. That may be by providing time to escape (the situation) or by inflicting sufficient injury to the aggressor that they can't continue their assault.

Sparring teaches neither of those attributes.



“Sparring teaches you how to utilize the instructed techniques”



  This is completely inaccurate. 90% of the instructed techniques are not allowed for use during these “matches” (at least in "Oyata's" system). How, Is this considered to be (productive) “training”? The use of “padding” limits the use/effectiveness of numerous “strikes”. This eliminates numerous “natural” reactions to the delivered techniques. Those “reactions” are part of one's technique choice(s) (whether injurious or not). Those reactions are not necessarily “injury's” (sustained), but they naturally occur and are therefor a “part” of one's understanding of how to utilize the technique. Participating in the practice of Sparring teaches (the student) to not use those techniques.

  The use of padding, and the restriction of what techniques can be utilized, reduces this manner of training to the strongest/biggest person (always) being the victor. It is commonly stated that if both participants are of equal ability, yet one is “bigger/stronger”, that (bigger/stronger) individual will (always) be the victor. This is blatantly untrue/inaccurate. Combatants are never “equal” in their abilities. Everyone has a “bad day”, or “makes the wrong move/provides the wrong opening”. On any given day, one (of the two) individual may be subject to “some” disadvantage (be it “physical”, or “mental”).

  Every (so-called) “advantage”, can be become a “disadvantage”. Most (so-called) “advantages” are based upon “sparring” standards. When the confrontation occurs in “the real world”, those “advantages” lose most of their value. “Sparring” allows those advantages to be utilized, reality doesn't (unless the defender allows them to be). “Size” is rarely proven to be a determining factor, knowledge proves to be the greater “advantage” (regardless of “size/strength”).



  To address one of the commonly used “excuses” (that many people will use), people will state that “their” (systems) techniques are too “deadly”(?) to use during “sparring”. Yes, numerous techniques have the potential to dislocate joints and/or cause a serious injury (which obviously, can't be utilized in a “sparring” match, between fellow students). There are very few techniques that can't be controlled (yet recognized as having the potential to of caused injury) to prevent inflicting that injury. This (of course) depends on the ability's of the student.

  This goes back to the practice of sparring, “stopping” a match for any (supposedly) correctly delivered strike (“contact” does not equate to correctly delivered, IMO). Rarely will those strikes of “stopped” the opponent (in an actual confrontation), yet “matches” (being a sport) will (often) “restart” the match. This instills a “false” belief in a techniques efficiency.

  The reality is, that the majority of physical confrontations are not (and are far from being) “life-threatening”. One's use of those “too deadly to use in a sparring match” techniques, are not relevant (for use during a common confrontation). IMO, this goes back to the (often touted) “we are training to be a warrior” mentality, which is both false and misleading. Unless you are in the Military, you are NOT any manner of a “warrior”. You are nothing more (or less) than a person who doesn't want to get their ass kicked (too badly, or at all).


  Schools that focus their students training on “sparring”, are (basically) instilling the belief that unless you are bigger and/or stronger (than your opponent), you will not be capable of defending yourself. Why would you begin training at a school that has (and emphasizes) that mentality? The (intended) purpose for the majority of systems don't teach this belief (yet, many will still emphasize “sparring” for their adult students).

  The manner that “sparring” is commonly done, has NO relationship to how the vast majority of altercations begin or occur. It “trains” the student to (often unnecessarily) create that situation, if/when that situation doesn't continue/occur in that (“practiced”) manner, the student is placed at a (great) disadvantage.


  I've had (numerous) persons choose to debate me on this matter. I'm (usually) given various (often extravagant) “examples” of why/how “I'm” wrong (about the listed opinions). The majority of those rebuts, are based upon (some) elaborate example that they provide. There's usually some extraordinary circumstance(s) that are included in those examples. Those “examples” are FAR from the “norm” (of a commonly occurring physical confrontation). Almost all, could have been avoided prior to that confrontation's occurrence.

  I've been involved in numerous confrontations (both professionally, and as a “victim”). NONE of those confrontations have had ANY similarity to a “sparring” situation, nor would that manner of practice aided me in any of them (when they did occur).  
 Only in “2” of those confrontations, would I have been “likely”(?) justified in the use of a technique that could of caused the potential for that individual to die from it's use. Those techniques were never even considered (by myself) for use. One, I was able to (verbally) nullify (thereby avoid), the other, I was able to escape from, to a position of safety and was able to “arm” myself (the aggressor, who was also armed, quickly left). The remainder were (ridiculous) matters of “bruised ego” and/or perceived incidents of “disrespect”(sic).

  When I was involved in a “professional” situation/confrontation, the “sparring” (model?) was equally irrelevant. Those situations placed myself as being the “aggressor”(?) to “deal with/remove” the subject. What is taught in Oyata's system (generally) doesn't “train” one, to perform those “duties”. That training only becomes applicable if/when the suspect/person becomes combative (during the situation).

  One's training should be for dealing with those situations that are most likely to occur. That doesn't include “sparring” situations. Those are “agreed” upon confrontations (that are rarely “life threatening”). Many (if not most) of my “professional” confrontations, were completed via limb manipulation/control (type) applications. Several began as (what could, or attempted to become) “fight” situations, but were avoided and/or reduced to being compliance scenarios. Those that argue that “Tuite and/or limb manipulations” have limited application, don't understand how/why they should or can be utilized. The majority of what I've seen (being taught), lead to creating “openings” to allow for strikes to be implemented. To myself, this (only) defines the instructor's limitations (in instructional abilities/knowledge).

  Tuite is (only) another piece of the instructed (in our case, Oyata's) art. It is used as it becomes (or is made to be) applicable. When used in conjunction with the other instructed motions, it allows one to neutralize an aggressor while maintaining control of any (further) aggressive behavior. Though having the potential to be escalated (to more injurious levels), that potential is rarely required.



  Do I feel that (some form of) “sparring” can be made to be practical (for practice)? Yes, I do. We utilize a form of it (though it bears little semblance to what is commonly being done). We will have “1” student put on the protective gear. Depending on the practiced motion/application, that student could be (either) the “tori” or the “uke”. The practiced “confrontation” is limited to 1-3 strike/grab attempts (by the uke). Motions rarely exceed that number of motions (by either party). Both, because it is unnecessary (unless the technique is misapplied), and (when done correctly) the uke is unable to do so. This method is began slowly (for acclimation / familiarization to the motions), and is increased in speed until the (aggressor's) strikes are “full power” (hence the gear). Depending upon the motion, “who” (needs to) wears the protective gear can vary. This is “our” version of “1-3” motion kumite.
 There has been several of our (new) students who have argued that this practice is “unrealistic”. Once they've participated (in the practice) they (then) understand our reasoning. Their disagreement is usually based upon (their own) false understandings of “how” a fight occurs (or how that attempt is neutralized) . There is no opportunity for the “trading” of strikes (though they are allowed), the ability of an aggressor (to continue) is commonly nullified (with correct application of the instructed motions).

  Interestingly, when the uke is allowed “multiple” strike attempts, they are rarely able (or allowed by the tori) to complete them. The most “productive” sessions (for the uke), are when the uke is allowed only 1 strike attempt. When multiple attempts are allowed, they will tend to focus on their final strike (though rarely are able to complete it).

  What we've found, is that students (initially) believe that one will need to perform a continuous repetition of “strikes” to neutralize an aggressor. Oyata taught that only a few “strikes” are (or should be) required to achieve that objective. Properly applied “control” techniques can then be utilized to neutralize the majority of aggressors.



  All said, “sparring” is great (fun?) for “kids”. I don't teach kids, so it's “purpose/usefulness” is nullified. I enjoyed it in my “younger” years, but (quickly) realized it's uselessness in relation to actual confrontations. 




Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Order of Priority








“Strikes are the primary weapon for defense. But if that defense is breached, we practice trips, sweeps, throws, and takedowns; and “then” basic grappling techniques.”


  I read this recently in a blog, where the individual was lamenting over how martial arts had changed through the years since he had begun studying (some 20 to 30 years ago). I read this, and agreed with his (basic) premise, but feel that this order (of priorities) was wrong then, and it is wrong now.
One could argue that in times past, society was more prone to violent confrontations, but I don't believe that to be an accurate summation. Violent (physical) behavior has never been a socially accepted method of settling disagreements. A person recognized as an asshole 2-300 years ago, is no different than their modern day equivalent.
Misogyny was more prevalent (in the past), but that didn't mean that physical altercations were any more socially acceptable than they are today (the “laws” in that regard that were in place then, were very similar to those in place today).
The subliminal implication being made (within that statement), is that “might (tends to) make right”. The (obvious) refute to that statement, is that any laws that a society has put in place discourage and have punished individual's who have participated in anti-social behavior (IE. Physical altercations). If it were (at all) accurate, then only bullies and brutes would be the individual's dictating the standards for social behavior.
The (age old) argument, is that “criminals” don't follow laws (which is true). The problem is that you are rarely going to be involved in an altercation with a criminal. The majority of physical altercations are between two (basically) “law-abiding” persons, who (for whatever stupid excuse) get into a dispute that turns physical. Those altercations commonly have no intention of ending the life of (either of) the participants, but amount to establishing the “correctness/validity” of the participants' view (over the subject being disputed).
When pressed, most individual's recognize this fact. In today's society, being involved in a physical confrontation will commonly result in “legal” repercussions being included as well. The majority of the articles I have read tend to ignore this fact as well. They (somehow) believe that if they are “justified” (in their mind), then the law will be on their side. These people have never been involved in a legal battle where the “bad guy”, has a good lawyer. It is VERY easy for that lawyer to argue (to the judge) that you escalated the situation far beyond any reasonable level (for the situation). The mere fact that you train (in a martial art) will be used against you, and will be believed that you have violent inclinations, and used this “opportunity” to test them out (on their client).
Don't believe that you're going to even see, a jury. Your far more likely to be in front of a judge, with the person's lawyer describing everything (whether accurately, or not). The other party will rarely make any statements at all (the lawyer will present the majority, if not all arguments). And yes, people LIE all the time at these proceedings (including witnesses). If you don't have a superior number of (believable) witnesses for your side (and even that isn't a guarantee), you will lose.
In regards to the “order/priority” of those training subjects, the one provided by that individual was (IMO) completely backward. The “first” subject learned (when training), should be those “basic grappling technique's”, followed by the “trips, sweeps, throws, and takedowns” and completed with instruction in the systems methodology for the use of strikes/kicks.
Experience has shown (myself) that confrontations proceed on the basis of performed responses. If the confrontation remains verbal, there is less chance for a (physical) requirement/necessity to respond. As proximity is diminished, that need/belief escalates. “Pushes, grabs and shoves” are (commonly) used as taunts to motivate the individual to (physically) react/respond. Though (obviously) not intending to injure (but more to embarrass), that physical contact is (none the less) illegal (often providing the legal justification for a defensive response). Although being justified, that justification does not provide for an unlimited level/amount of response (meaning you can't dislocate someone's arm, crush their throat, and gouge out an eye, because someone pushed you).
Any level of response that you enact, will need to be seen as reasonable by the average individual. If/when there is a physical disparity between the (original) aggressor and the student (defender), they will have a greater chance of their defense being seen as a reasonable/expected reaction.
One's competence with the Tuite technique's will provide a defensive method that (when observed by any witnesses) provides a less violent appearance to the student's defensive motions. Its use (Tuite) can additionally discourage (though obviously not always prevent) the inclination to escalate the confrontation to more violent/physical levels.
The most popular argument regarding the use of Tuite is the (mistaken) belief that it doesn't work on/for “everybody”. I (personally) despise the words “always/never”, but as yet, we have not encountered an individual whom these applications have/will not “work” upon. It should be noted, that “Tuite” is not universal. Prior to “Oyata's” introducing it (here in the U.S.) I know that “I” had never seen/heard of it (and I had been practicing/teaching M.A. For a number of years before meeting Oyata). We only practiced some “Jujutsu/Aikido” types of “wrist/arm” manipulations. Nowadays, everybody teaches their own form of grappling/wrist applications, and have begun to (now) use the term “Tuite”.
Once those “grappling” applications are understood, the “Trips, throws and takedowns” are (much) more easily utilized. Either of these application methods (Tuite or the throws/takedowns) lead directly to the restraint/submission of an aggressor (with little to no need for “strikes” to be utilized).
Does this imply that I/we don't believe in striking? of course not. It simply isn't our primary defensive choice. The success of a Striking technique is subject to numerous factors that a student has limited (if any) control of. Striking focuses on many students basic instincts (unless that student is female and/or a smaller stature male). Those that believe the shown “grappling” techniques are dependent upon having (enough) “strength/size” (for their use upon an opponent), don't understand the technique's (to begin with).
Striking techniques will vary in their effectiveness, because of circumstances that are often beyond the control of the student. If that student is only (attempting to) focusing their attention on (including) physical “power” with their strikes, they will only achieve limited levels of success. Power equates to the transferred momentum of a given mass. That transfer is accomplished thru speed, leverage, and (sufficient) penetration. Equally relevant is the impacted location, and the angle of that impact. This shouldn't (necessarily) be equated to the use of kyusho (study/instruction), only logic.
If/when an impact is perceived (by the recipient) as being direct/straight, the manner they react will be different if/when that impact is other than their initial belief/perception. This is similar to if/when one “twists” their ankle, they perceived a different tread point/location (than what actually existed), and the subject trips/stumbles (injuring their own ankle). An aggressor's perceptions can be manipulated with proper training (this was one of Oyata's most popular subjects for instruction).
  Through arrangement in this order, a student is provided with (more) applicable technique's earlier in their study. 




Thursday, February 18, 2016

Purpose of kata


  The concept of “bunkai” (techniques illustrated within the motions of kata) has become the latest “fad” in the martial arts. It's always been there, but has only recently (the past 20 years) become an integral part of martial arts instruction.
  Kata motions have always been interpreted as representing “techniques” (in varying degrees of complexity). This latest wave of motions (techniques?) is only the latest examples of what those motions “could” represent. I state could, because we (modern students) don't really know what the original creator's intended those motions to represent. The original creator's of the “traditional” kata are dead and gone. Virtually every interpretation taught, is an opinion of what those motions represent. Each of those varying interpretations are based upon the (individual) instructors viewpoint (opinion).
  The majority of those interpretations focus upon (individual, or even “combinations”of) “techniques”. When I view the provided “video examples” of these interpretations, it makes me wonder why these person's would believe that the creator's of those kata (a “master”), would only demonstrate “techniques” within them? It would be more “practical” to of produced a book (or some form of written document) listing examples of those motions/techniques.
  Numerous “modern” instructors have (attempted) to make “their own” text/book(s) listing techniques, but the majority of them only amount to their own listings of techniques (with various references to kata motion). I don't feel there's anything wrong with their doing so, but (IMO) they “miss” many of the additional (and often more important) concepts that are illustrated within the kata.
“Techniques” are often subjective (to situations, circumstances and the individual's abilities). When that's a consideration, the value of demonstrating a technique motion becomes questionable (and is obvious when viewing the numerous “examples” of individual's interpretations of those motions that are being presented).
  Many (if not most) are based upon some physical (“muscular”) ability to perform them. Oyata taught that “techniques” (at least the techniques that “he” taught) were not based upon the physical size of the practitioner, or the uke (for their success). To myself at least, this makes sense. If/when one is “creating” a defensive system, it should be applicable by anyone, regardless of size, sex or physical prowess. The vast majority of “techniques” that are demonstrated (on the Internet) are being shown/demonstrated by (often) large(er), male practitioners. Granted, the majority of MA practitioners are “male”, but that fact shouldn't thereby (IMO) limit the choice of techniques taught/utilized.
  When a technique is based upon physical size/strength, that technique (though “valid”) should not be included as a curriculum requirement (though possibly remain as a valid “option” for certain students). Within “our” classes instruction, we just eliminate them (from consideration for instruction). They may be “exampled” for the student's familiarity with them, but they are not taught as a “requirement”.
  The majority of those techniques (because of their dependency upon size/strength) contain numerous “weaknesses” as well. Those “flaws” are illustrated to students, and the student can decide the techniques value (for their own use).
  Oyata taught that every kata motion represented numerous interpretations. At the “basic” level, they (might) represent “technique” application, but he (Taika) focused upon the “other” concepts taught through the motions of the kata. These included body-weight placement/transfer, leverage strengths/weaknesses, “natural” (verses “unnatural”) motion. All of which, is what we (now) refer to as “Force Efficiency”. Oyata also included (what he referred to as) the use of “deception” (best defined as “hiding” the defenders initial application of technique). Though commonly “exampled” in the instructed (individual) techniques, it was (often) the “main” purpose of demonstrating many of those techniques (to begin with).
  What the (majority of) attending students of his “seminars” (early 80's/90's) “missed”, was recognizing that instruction. The shown “techniques” were irrelevant (in his opinion), But they were what those attendee's focused upon. Oyata taught “concepts”. Individual techniques were irrelevant, it was the presented “concept/principle” that was important (and was demonstrated within the shown application).
  Those “principles” were often “missed” by the majority of those attendee's. There are (now) numerous videos from those attendee's that state “I learned this technique from Oyata” (which is a bit of an exaggeration IMO). The techniques that Oyata demonstrated at those seminars were “basic” examples of principles. The techniques (though valid), were irrelevant. It was the principle being shown that was important (to the application of numerous techniques). He (Taika) expected the student to (then) apply the instructed principle to (all of) their “other” techniques. Oyata was (very) adamant that a student should be “studying” their techniques (not just “replicating” the motions).
  One's ability to replicate a technique, only requires practice (repetition). To understand what/why that technique will/won't “work”, requires devoted study of the technique. The kata provides examples of the (previously stated) attributes that make the correct performance of those motions possible.
  Limiting one's “study” to guessing what “technique” a motion represents, is (itself) “limiting” what one can/will learn from the kata motion. Because I have “electrical” experience, I equate this study to that of electrical circuitry. At it's simplest level, one has an “on/off” switch with a light and the connecting “wiring”. If/when that concept is extrapolated (far enough) one can construct a computer (which is basically a multitude of “on/off” switches).  
 Though not exactly a direct correlation, the concept is the same. One needs to understand everything that is being demonstrated within the kata motions. It isn't (only) about the (obvious) “techniques”. The majority of what I've seen demonstrated on the Internet, is (often) equivalent to the ability to wire a “3-way switch”. It' useful, but a far cry from the potential of what's being shown.
  Oyata (often) stated that “he” still had much to learn. His instructors didn't focus their instruction (to him) on individual “techniques”. They provided him with a certificate that stated (to anyone else) that he had understood that instruction. That certificate states that nothing about his learning/instruction was in regards to “techniques”. He had learned the ability to utilize the “principles” of their systems, many of which are demonstrated within the instructed kata. If/when one understands those principles, “techniques” will then become obvious (regardless of the kata utilized).
  The majority of certificates produced (today) will list that the individual has demonstrated their ability of performing the instructed “techniques” (for that system). Techniques are arbitrary, and are subject to circumstance. Principles are enduring and apply to a greater understanding (of the provided instruction). This is what Oyata's system (and our students instruction) focuses upon. Kata, is the “manual” that exists to provide that knowledge. 




Thursday, February 11, 2016

Achieving Force Efficiency



 The achievement of force efficiency with one's technique application (regardless of the manor of that application) is performed though the utilization of the entire bodies weight, as well as it's stability while delivering the application. To do this the student will need to study the individual limb's motions as well as the alignment of the body during the application of those techniques.
 Optimal efficiency is achieved through proper stance, torso positioning and technique delivery.
 In evaluating the efficiency of those motions, one initially considers the utilized limb (arm or leg), then should consider the efficiency of the (remaining) entire body (while delivering that strike).
 Initially considering “Strikes”, these can be either extensions or lateral “swings” of the utilized limb. The most efficient manor for delivering momentum and force, are through the “extensions” (of the utilized limb) that are combined with the inclusion of body weight being used in conjunction with that motion. Lateral “swings” are the more popularly used manor of striking an opponent (whether aggressively or defensively). They are unfortunately also the “weaker” choice of/for an application, and are the more easily deflected and/or avoided through (defensive) motion.
 Though (direct) redirection/avoidance is the more easily achieved response, physical intervention (contact) will produce a (defensively) more efficient result. Correctly doing so, can additionally unbalance the striking individual, and has the potential to create opportunities for (further) defensive “counter” measures.
 Though lateral (defensive) strikes/deflections are what is more/most commonly taught, they are (most often) being performed in opposition to the bodies “natural” motions. Oyata's methodology emphasizes performing those motions in accordance with the bodies (naturally) most efficient manor.
 This entails the user utilizing their entire body (body-weight) with any/every performed motion. This is often equated to a (circular) “swinging” bucket of water, the “problem” (with this analogy) is that energy (momentum) will only (efficiently) travel in a straight line. Therefor the created force (through the circular motion) of the body, is constantly moving outward, and rearward (on the opposite side) as well. The retraction of the opposite side (arm, hip, shoulder) is motioning in the opposite direction (along with any momentum created through that motion).
 If the entire body is not motioning in the same direction (as the strike), that energy is wasted (non-productive) in relation to the strike. Energy/momentum will only travel (efficiently) in a single (straight) direction. The only (accurate) way to equate the “swinging” bucket of water (which is "the" most commonly utilized analogy), is if the bucket is swung with the open end of the bucket pointed outward (which demonstrates that the water will exit the bucket in every direction until empty, leaving only the weight of the bucket itself).
 Neither energy, nor momentum will travel in a circular motion (without a counter-force acting upon it). The “mistake” that people make, is that doing so (motioning their hips/body) is in believing that because it “feels” more powerful, that it (actually) is. When a motion is (truly) efficient, the user should not “feel” anything (other than the impact).
 Oyata stressed the utilization of a (more) direct force application. Though not always delivered in a “straight” line, the motion was a consistent extension (of the limb/body) in a single direction. This meant that arm motions (such as the motions commonly referred to as “blocks”) were performed as extensions, not as lateral “swings”, as the aforementioned “blocks” are commonly performed. When these arm motions are performed as (forward) extensions, the entire bodies weight can (then) be included with that motion.
 The brain is capable of evaluating the direction/attitude of an approaching impact. The brain will (attempt to) resist/absorb that strike (as to how the body perceives it). That is commonly perceived as a being a direct (straight-line) impact. If/when that impact is “other” than being direct, the performed actions (on the part of the receiver's body) are inefficient (at absorbing/resisting that impact). For that reason, Oyata taught that an impact (regardless of the manor/type being used) should include a lateral motion included with (commonly at the “end” of) the impact.
 This concept is initially taught with a students performance of the “milking” punch. This striking method adds a lateral rotation of the user's wrist just following/included within it's initial impact.
 To maintain the entire bodies stability, the hips must remain aligned with the user's shoulders. If/when that alignment is altered, the utilized limb's motion is unstable (and thus, inefficient). This will apply to either an arm or a leg motion. This “alignment” is initially practiced in the students performance of the instructed kata. If/when that alignment is altered through various “superficial/extra” body motions (“hip/shoulder/waist” rotation), the alignment/efficiency of the performed actions are diminished.
 The majority of these “extra” motions, are commonly being included in the attempt to extend one's range (and are thus emphasizing that the user wasn't properly positioned to begin with).  The argument is often made that it is more “powerful” (it isn't), it may “feel” more powerful, but as stated previously, if/when the motion is performed properly, it shouldn't be “felt” by the user (as all of the created force/momentum is being transferred into the target), except at the point of impact (by the striking limb).
 The concept of being “rooted” is (often) being misapplied/perceived as well. Being “rooted”, is simply being stable (in balance). This shouldn't imply immobility. If/when one exaggerates this concept, they will become unstable if/when moving. Stability should be a factor during one's (body) motion as well. One's concern is (commonly) during their changing of stances (movement). Stability (in motion) can only be maintained in limited directions while doing so. That is commonly recognized only in (direct) relation (both with, and away from) the direction being moved (commonly forward/back, though side to side is equally applicable).
 Body rotation should include “correctional” motion(s) as well (thus providing those additional 2 directions of increased stability). This is the concept that “rooting” is attempting to convey, it should not be equated to immobility.
 The most susceptible portion of the body to an aggressor, is the lower body (ie. The “legs”). A student should include attention upon protecting the lower body. Even though the majority of aggressive actions are performed above the waist, the lower body remains the most vulnerable to being struck/injured. In that effort, students are taught numerous stances, not that these positions will (entirely) protect the lower body (legs) from any aggressive actions, they can limit their vulnerability.
 Every stance has is (own) vulnerabilities. Circumstances will dictate which of those stances are the most efficient for the given situation. Understanding those vulnerabilities will allow the student to utilize them against/upon their opponent/aggressor as well (when those vulnerabilities are present). Stances are constantly being changed during a confrontation. Any vulnerabilities should be recognized as they occur, or are being created (through the actions of the user).
 Depending upon the strike being utilized (by the tori), their stance can enhance or diminish the available force/momentum available with it. Understanding the most efficient delivery method for the utilized limb is determined through proper stance, efficient limb motion, body (torso) and foot positioning and proper (effective) distancing (range). These factors are pieces of what constitute what we refer to, as “Force Efficiency”.